During my 15 years of selling books in a retail environment, I developed a process to decide on purchasing a book for resale. Here is my list in order of priority 1-9 with number 10 being the most critical for religious books.

1. Topic and Content and length

2. Cover Design

3. Print Quality and layout design

4. Title and Subtitle

5. Publisher Credibility

6. Forward and Endorsements Credibility

7. Author Credentials

8. Table of Contents and Chapter Titles

9. Price and Availability and Marketing

10. Theology and use of Scripture


TOPIC AND CONTENT AND LENGTH

  1. Is the topic intended for a specific audience (wife of an evangelical pastor) or a nearly universal audience (God’s love in the midst of hard relationships)?
  2. Does the concept of the book start with God and reach down to us (The Radical Disciple, John Piper) or does it start with us and reach up to God (The Purpose Driven Life, Rick Warren)?
  3. Is it a hot-topic that people want to learn more about such as God’s purpose for my life, (Just Do Something, Kevin DeYoung) or one that should be pursued but won’t likely be (White Picket Fences, Amy Julia Becker)?
  4. Who does the author quote? C.S Lewis and Abraham Lincoln or politicians and celebrities? Written word, spoken word, or a voice on the internet?
  5. Are visual teaching elements, such as diagrams or charts, included to aid the learning process?
  6. Are there reliable statistics to compel a change in thinking?
  7. Does the topic require 300 pages or might 100 have been more suitable?
  8. If intended for a male audience on the topic of relationships, is it mercifully short?
  9. If for children, will the readers (dads, moms, and kids) identify with the characters and the message?

Note: Most books are too long.


Cover Design

  1. If sitting on an airplane and a stranger sees me reading this book, will I be embarrassed?
  2. Does the cover design/photo limit the appeal to a certain gender/age group/demographic?
  3. Is there something that makes a book cover displeasing to some audiences, such as a picture of a snake or clown?
  4. Is the book thick enough (page count) to be able to sit on a shelf with the spine out and have the spine function as part of the marketing with the title and author clearly readable?
  5. What is the binding? If it is spiral-bound saddle-stitched I would normally skip the title due to the need to have it face out in order to market.
  6. What is the size? If it is too large to fit on a shelf it will need to be located in an area separated from its normal category or on the top shelf out of its normal alphabetical order. If too small it may be easily lost on the shelf or require a special display rack.
  7. When listed online with other books, will it be visually lost in the background color of the page? (Amazon, Barnes and Noble and ChristianBook all have white backgrounds.)
  8. When listed online with other books, will it stand out as compared to other images?
  9. Does the color scheme of the book match the intended emotion of the book? (A black and white cover design on the topic of hope does not make sense to me.)

Note: Everyone judges books by their cover. Simple is often better.


Print Quality and Interior Layout

  1. Paper feel: cover and pages
  2. Font selection and line spacing – is it readable?
  3. Is it black and white only or does it have color accents?
  4. Are there artistic details such as print accents, section headers, call-outs, and background shading to create the appearance of value and intentionality?
  5. Are there blank spaces where blank spaces should be?
  6. Is there sufficient white space in the margins to take notes?
  7. Do all of the chapters begin on a page on the right?

Note: Books need to feel like books. Matte finishes are more inviting.


Title and Subtitle

  1. Do the title and subtitle clearly express the message of the book?
  2. Do they identify a target audience?
  3. Do they offer a promise? Present and solve a problem?
  4. Is it witty? Does it make me curious?
  5. Is it confusing?
  6. Is it offensive? Too provocative? Too shaming?

Note: Creative often means ambiguous. The book’s title should get me to read the subtitle. The subtitle should make me pick up the book to read the summary on the back.


Publisher Credibility

  1. Who is the publisher?
  2. Is there name recognition to me? Will there be for customers?
  3. What is the reputation of the publisher?
  4. Does the publisher have a track record of publishing this genre?
  5. Does the publisher have a reputation for this genre?
  6. Do they claim to publish a certain ideology but not others? Is that good in this scenario?
  7. If a book on this topic was available from another publisher, would I choose to sell that one instead?

Note: I have favorite publishers.


Forward and Endorsements Credibility

  1. The reverse of “who does the author quote,” who is willing to associate their reputation with this author/publisher/book/topic?
  2. Is there name recognition to me? To customers?
  3. What books have the endorsers written?
  4. What are their other credentials? Degrees? Experience? Profession?

Note: When searching for new titles to stock in our store I would regularly search for books for which my favorite authors had written the forward. That was enough for me to trust the book.


Author Credentials

  1. Who is the author?
  2. Is there name recognition to me? To customers?
  3. Has she written other books? What topics? How well did they sell?
  4. What is her credibility on the topic? Degrees? Experience? Profession?
  5. Is the author part of any personal or professional networks to help me understand who he is and what he believes and what the agenda of the work might be?

Note: Authors rarely have credibility on their own. This is why a publisher, foreword, endorsements, and following are crticial.


Table of Contents and Chapter Titles

  1. Similar to the title and subtitle, do they clearly express the message of the book?
  2. Could a person read only the chapter titles and benefit from the author’s expertise?
  3. Are they ambiguous and thus an imposition to helping the potential buyer decide to say yes?
  4. Are there clear sections that reveal a roadmap for the reader?

Note: One of my favorite Table of Contents is found in Sacred Marriage, by Gary Thomas.


Price and Availability and Marketing

  1. Is the price right for the audience? Textbooks will cost more than children’s books.
  2. Is the paperback priced at more than $20? Is the hardcover priced at more than $30?
  3. Is there a standard discount (41%+) available to our store to ensure profit margin?
  4. Is there sufficient inventory in stock with the publisher or distributor to reorder the book after it sells?
  5. Is it returnable?
  6. Can the book be purchased at the same time as other books?
  7. Does the book have a marketing plan that is being executed by the publisher and/or author or other influencers?
  8. Is there a movie tie-in?
  9. Is there a cultural movement on the topic?
  10. Does the season of the year merit consideration of the book?

Note: Buying and selling books is a business decision.


Theology and use of Scripture

  1. Does this author develop their message and themes from scripture?
  2. Is there any abuse of scripture to make a point?
  3. Is the bible referenced as an idea or is it quoted as the authority?
  4. If quoted, is it only single verses lost in the text of paragraphs or is it full passages formatted to draw the attention of the reader?
  5. Does the author appear to be selecting verses from various translations so as to justify their agenda?

Note: How one uses scripture and prays convey much about what they believe about God and themselves.